Today, a guest post by Anne Roberts. Anne Roberts is a freelance writer. She writes blog posts, how-to articles, SEO copies, and many other types of content for several websites. Anne is currently a web content writer for personal injury attorneys. (But we like her anyway!!)
Explaining Negligence in the Construction Industry
The construction world can be regarded as one of the most dangerous industries to work in. Because of the inherent hazards that come with working on a construction or repair project, both construction professionals and laborers uphold certain standards to ensure a safe working environment.
Contractors, surveyors, engineers, project managers to employers–all have a duty of care to observe. They make sure that assessments of risks involved in any facet of construction are made. Laborers, on the other hand, benefit from the assessments by exercising preventive measures.
Still, accidents happen.
Some of the most common accidents that occur in construction sites involve six-feet-or-more falls from ladders or stairs. Other accidents are caused by the failure to implement safety precautions, such as improper building of scaffolding, use of dangerous tools and unsafe machinery, and other hazardous issues. Without proper implementation of safety precautions, working on an elevated surface may result to debilitating injuries and even death.
According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), it has been estimated that fatal accidents involving construction workers accounted for 15 percent of all job-related deaths in the U.S. Such injuries or deaths may not have happened if a certain construction or repair project employed safety rules or standards of care. Such occurrence is categorized as construction negligence.
When a serious accident happens, usually all parties involved are brought into the litigation, as cross-allegations of construction safety issues, construction defects, and construction administration/observation/inspection issues. In North Carolina, an employee cannot sue his employer for a workplace accident (but instead seek a workers’ compensation recovery). The employee can, however, bring a negligence action against any/all (other) responsible third parties. [Editor’s Note: The parties may have rights to recover against each other if one is actively negligent and one is only passively negligent. Otherwise, joint & several liability applies.]
To establish negligence, the injured party must prove the following four factors:
- The construction professionals involved have a duty of care;
- They breached or violated that duty of care;
- The breach of duty of care resulted to an injury; and
- The injury was the result of the construction professionals’ negligence.
[Editor’s Note: The injured party also must not have been contributorily negligent.]
Other than in a construction or repair project site, construction negligence also happens on highway construction and post-construction efforts. Unsafe conditions during roadwork can be considered negligence, especially if workers, as well as motorists, consequently sustained certain injuries.
Even a complete building can be a source of negligence, in which the contractor or subcontractor failed to adhere to building codes. Construction defects, such as low structural integrity of the building, mechanical and electrical failure, and low-quality finishes, may lead to injuries and deaths.
Melissa again: Thanks Anne for your post! Readers: Watch this space– I’m planning on posting an infographic tomorrow that will show construction accidents & related statistics. Stay tuned. In the meantime, please leave any questions or thoughts in the comment section, below.
Photo of workers on bamboo scaffolding (c) Terrance TS Tam.
[Update 12:42 pm ET, 11/3/11– CA is for Construction Contract Administration, or “Contract Administration” for short- thanks Liz O’Sullivan]
One of the Architect’s responsibilities on a construction project is that of
construction contract administration (“CA”). While not every contract contemplates the architect performing a CA role, most commercial construction projects do. What, exactly, should be included in the CA role? The CA role can be whatever the parties agree upon. In fact, the AIA A201 form contract documents anticipate that the architect’s role will be defined in an exhibit.
ConstructionConstruction Contract Administration§ 4.2.10 If the Owner and Architect agree, the Architect will provide one or more project representatives to assist in carrying out the Architect’s responsibilities at the site. The duties, responsibilities and limitations of authority of such project representatives shall be as set forth in an exhibit to be incorporated in the Contract Documents.
- What frequency is contemplated for visits?
- How long should those visits last?
- What is your role during such site visits?
Does your designer contract have provisions in it for additional compensation in the event the construction project takes longer than the parties anticipate? If you use the AIA 201 (2007) general conditions for the Contractor, it may. The AIA provisions include:
§ 1.1.2 THE CONTRACT
The Contract Documents form the Contract for Construction. The Contract represents the entire and integrated agreement between the parties hereto and supersedes prior negotiations, representations or agreements, either written or oral. The Contract may be amended or modified only by a Modification. The Contract Documents shall not be construed to create a contractual relationship of any kind (1) between the Contractor and the Architect or the Architect’s consultants, (2) between the Owner and a Subcontractor or a Sub-subcontractor, (3) between the Owner and the Architect or the Architect’s consultants or (4) between any persons or entities other than the Owner and the Contractor. The Architect shall, however, be entitled to performance and enforcement of obligations under the Contract intended to facilitate performance of the Architect’s duties.
The language that I bolded is very important language. It may provide a mechanism to recoup additional service fees for extended construction administration services. Note, however, that I said “may.”
If your fees are based on a set number of construction days, what happens if the project gets extended? Do you simply go without pay for extra months of CA services? Do you re-negotiate with the Owner at that time? You should consider this issue in advance to avoid disputes later on.
Best practice? A clause in the Owner-Designer contract that states that additional services compensation will kick in after a certain date, at a set value per month.
If you wait until the issue comes up during the final phase of construction, you have much less bargaining power. You also run the risk of the Owner claiming errors and omissions against you when you present a bill for extra services. Deal with the issue up front, in much the same way that unit prices for rock overages are provided for upfront in the contractor’s contract.
Do you have experience with getting additional compensation after construction delays? What worked best for your company? Share below.
And, sign up for email delivery of blog posts to your mailbox!
Photo (c) Freefoto.com via Creative Commons license.
The threat of a contract termination, especially one “for cause” as opposed to “for convenience” , is something that strikes terror in the heart of many contractors. The request by an owner to terminate for cause is something that must be handled carefully by the design professional/contract administrator. A misstep by any party can cost untoward damages relating to contract termination in the construction context.