Certificate of Merit to sue architects or engineers? (Tue Tip)

You know how they say the best laid plans can go awry?  Just as unforeseen issues pop up in construction, they also pop up in the practice of law.  So, while it is still Tuesday, I apologize for the late hour of my post.

I bring you good tidings, despite my lateness.  Right now, in the North Carolina General Assembly, is a proposed bill that would require a Certificate of Merit to be filed in civil litigation against an architect, engineer, or a design firm.  If it passes, this would require that an unbiased, third party (who is also a licensed professional) has reviewed the claim and believes it has merit.  

boy holding certificate of merit

This boy has his certificate of merit: will lawsuits against architects and engineers require the same?

Such a pre-lawsuit requirement  has long been a right that doctors enjoy.  Now, there may a chance for architects and engineers to also enjoy protection from otherwise frivolous lawsuits. 

The bill has been introduced, had its first reading, and has been referred to the Judiciary Committee.  While the bill is a long way from passage, it is a good sign that the public recognizes too often professionals are the targets in lawsuits simply because of their “deep pockets” (really!) or their insurance coverage. 

You can keep track of the progress of Senate Bill 435 here

(h/t to Kathryn Westcott, ACEC-NC Executive Director)

Photo: (c) John Dolan via Flickr/Creative Commons License.

2 thoughts on “Certificate of Merit to sue architects or engineers? (Tue Tip)

  1. Devon Thurtle Anderson says:

    Oregon has had a similar requirement for several years now. Generally, plaintiffs won’t file until they already have experts lined up anyway. Having represented plaintiffs in Oregon in cases against design professionals, fulfilling the requirement is generally a non-issue.

    • MelissaBrumback says:

      You sound like a lawyer who actually does his due diligence before filing a lawsuit. Unfortunately, all too often in NC I’ve seen the lawsuit get filed first, and then the plaintiffs scramble to get a standard of care expert much later on, sometimes in response to a motion for summary judgment because they haven’t, to that point, identified any experts. So this will be a bit of a game changer here for those types of cases and attorneys.

Got a comment? Please share!!!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.